EDEXCEL GCSE HISTORY · PAPER 1 · CRIME & PUNISHMENT
Crime and Punishment in Anglo-Saxon England
c1000-1066 · Chapter 1: Crime and punishment in medieval England, c1000-1066 · Lesson 1 of 4
What Do You Already Think?
Answer before the lesson, then check your ideas at the end.
1. Who would catch a thief in a village with no police?
The villagers themselves, through the hue and cry and the tithing.
2. How could a court decide guilt with no evidence?
Oaths from respected neighbours, or trial by ordeal - letting God decide.
3. Were there prisons?
Hardly any. Gaols held people awaiting trial; prison was not a punishment.
4. Who made the laws?
The king, through written law codes, with local custom alongside.
Learning Objectives
1. Identify crimes against the person, property and authority in Anglo-Saxon England.
2. Explain how tithings, the hue and cry and the local courts kept order without a police force.
3. Describe how guilt was decided, including oaths and trial by ordeal.
4. Explain the aims of Anglo-Saxon punishments, including wergild.
Setting the Scene
Around 1000, England was a Christian kingdom of small villages where almost everyone knew everyone. The king kept the King's Peace by issuing law codes, but he had no police force and few officials. Law and order depended on the community: villagers were expected to catch, accuse and bring wrongdoers to court themselves.
c1000 - England is divided into shires, and each shire into hundreds, each with its own court. | c1008 - King Aethelred's law codes set out the duties of free men and the penalties for crime. | c1020 - King Cnut's law codes restate the tithing, the hue and cry and wergild. | 1066 - The Norman conquest - the end of the Anglo-Saxon system as a system of its own.
Types of Crime
Historians sort medieval crime into three kinds - the exam expects you to use them.
|
Crimes against the person Murder, assault, rape. Treated as harm done to a family, who expected compensation. |
Crimes against property Theft, robbery, arson, poaching. Theft was by far the most common crime. |
|
Crimes against authority Treason - betraying the king or your lord - and rebellion. The most serious crime of all. |
Moral crimes Adultery, drunkenness, failing to attend church. Dealt with by the Church. |
|
Why theft dominated Most people were poor farmers; a stolen animal or tools could ruin a family. |
The King's Peace A crime was increasingly seen as a breach of the king's peace, not only harm to a victim. |
Keeping Order Without a Police Force
Every free man was part of a system that made his neighbours responsible for him.
▸ Tithings. Groups of ten men over the age of twelve who were responsible for each other's behaviour. If one broke the law, the others had to bring him to court or pay a fine.
▸ Hue and cry. A victim or witness raised the alarm and every man in the village had to stop work and chase the suspect. A village that failed to join in could be fined.
▸ The reeve. The king's local official. The shire-reeve - later the sheriff - brought suspects to court and collected fines.
▸ Collective responsibility. Because the whole community paid if it failed, everyone had a reason to keep watch on everyone else.
From Crime to Court
Every stage depended on ordinary people, not officials.
|
1 Hue and cry The alarm is raised and the village chases the suspect. |
2 Tithing answers If he escapes, his tithing must produce him at court or pay. |
3 Court meets The hundred court (monthly) or shire court (twice a year) hears the accusation in the open. |
4 Oath-helpers Respected men swear to the accused's good character - enough oaths could clear him. |
5 Ordeal If oaths could not settle it, the case went to God through trial by ordeal. |
Trial by Ordeal
|
When a court could not decide, it asked God. Ordeals took place in or near a church, after the accused had fasted and heard Mass, and a priest blessed the water or the iron. The four ordeals ▸ Hot iron. Carry a red-hot iron bar three paces. If the bandaged burn healed cleanly after three days, innocent. ▸ Hot water. Pick a stone out of boiling water. Judged by the healing of the hand, as with hot iron. ▸ Cold water. Lowered into blessed water: sinking meant innocent, floating meant the water had rejected you. ▸ Consecrated bread. For priests. Choke on the blessed bread and you were guilty. |
Guilt was left for God to reveal. |
Medieval manuscript illustration; look for a public domain copy on Wikimedia Commons.
How Offenders Were Punished
Punishment aimed at compensation and deterrence, not reform.
|
Punishment |
Used for |
Why |
|---|---|---|
|
Wergild |
Murder and injury |
Compensation to the family, set by the victim's rank, to stop blood feuds |
|
Fines |
Most minor crimes |
Paid to the victim, and increasingly to the king |
|
Stocks and pillory |
Petty crimes |
Public humiliation as a warning to others |
|
Mutilation |
Repeat offenders |
Cutting off a hand, ear or nose - a lasting mark and deterrent |
|
Execution |
Treason, repeat theft |
Hanging, for crimes that threatened the king or the community |
The Law in the King's Own Words
|
“And if anyone flees from the hue and cry, let him pay the wergild of the man he has slain, and let his tithing answer for him.” — Adapted from the law code of King Cnut, c1020 |
WHAT IT SHOWS Even the king's written law works through the tithing and the hue and cry - Anglo-Saxon justice depended on the community rather than on royal officials.
Key Terms
|
Tithing A group of ten men over twelve who were responsible for each other's behaviour. |
Hue and cry The duty of every villager to chase a suspect once the alarm was raised. |
|
Wergild "Man price": compensation paid to a victim's family, set by the victim's rank. |
Trial by ordeal A religious test asking God to show whether the accused was guilty. |
|
Oath-helpers Men who swore to the good character of the accused. |
King's Peace The idea that the king was responsible for keeping order across his kingdom. |
|
Reeve A local royal official; the shire-reeve became the sheriff. |
|
Summary
✓ Theft was the most common crime; treason the most serious.
✓ Order depended on the community: tithings, the hue and cry and local courts.
✓ Where oaths could not decide guilt, trial by ordeal left it to God.
✓ Punishments aimed at compensation (wergild) and deterrence, not prison.
|
EXAM FOCUS Explain why the community played such an important role in law enforcement in Anglo-Saxon England. (12 marks) Give at least three reasons, each explained with specific detail - and include one that goes beyond the stimulus points. |