Viewing as
Teaching this? The teacher view adds 2 files, the mark schemes and the model answers.
History · Crime and punishment in medieval England
Crime and Punishment in Norman England
What William the Conqueror kept, what he changed, and how much 1066 really altered the way England dealt with crime.
Starter: Anglo-Saxon Recap
Pair each term with its meaning.
-
Tithing
Ten men responsible for each other
-
Hue and cry
The village chases the suspect
-
Wergild
Compensation paid to the victim's family
-
Oath-helpers
Neighbours who swore to your character
-
Ordeal
Letting God decide guilt
Learning Objectives
- 1Explain why William I needed to control a hostile Anglo-Saxon population.
- 2Describe the new crimes and punishments the Normans introduced, including the Forest Laws and the murdrum fine.
- 3Explain the continuity in Norman law enforcement, and assess how much changed after 1066.
Setting the Scene
In 1066 William of Normandy won the Battle of Hastings, but around 10,000 Normans now had to rule about two million English people who resented them. Rebellions followed, and William crushed them brutally in the Harrying of the North (1069-70). His laws were designed to protect his power and his followers.
- 1066 Battle of Hastings: William becomes king.
- 1069-70 Harrying of the North: rebellion crushed by laying waste to the land.
- 1079 The New Forest is created as a royal hunting forest.
- 1086 The Domesday Book records who holds the land - and owes the king service.
- 1166 Henry II's Assize of Clarendon strengthens royal justice.
The Feudal System
Crime against your lord was now a crime against the whole structure of power.
-
1
The king
Owned all the land; granted it in return for loyalty
-
2
Barons and bishops
Held land from the king; supplied knights
-
3
Knights
Held land from barons; fought when called
-
4
Peasants
Worked the land; owed labour and obedience to their lord
What Changed and What Stayed the Same
Continuity from the Anglo-Saxons
- Tithings and the hue and cry still made communities police themselves.
- Hundred and shire courts still heard most cases.
- Trial by ordeal continued, run by the Church.
- Stocks, pillory, fines and execution were all still used.
Norman changes
- The Forest Laws created new crimes on royal land.
- The murdrum fine punished a hundred for a Norman's murder.
- Trial by combat was introduced.
- Wergild ended: fines went to the king, not the victim's family.
The Forest Laws
William declared large areas of England, including the New Forest, to be royal forest. People who had lived there for generations were suddenly criminals for doing what they had always done.
What became a crime
- Hunting Killing deer or boar on royal land - poaching.
- Everyday life Cutting wood, grazing animals or carrying a bow in the forest.
- Harsh penalties Poaching a deer could be punished by blinding or mutilation.
- A social crime Most people did not see poaching as really wrong, so many helped poachers.
Royal forests covered a large part of England by 1200.
Case study
The Murdrum Fine
Normans were being killed by resentful English people, and the killers were hard to find because locals protected each other. William's answer was the murdrum fine: if a Norman was found murdered and the killer was not handed over, the whole hundred where the body lay had to pay a very large fine. It used the Anglo-Saxon idea of collective responsibility, but turned it into a way of protecting the conquerors.
Punishment Under the Normans
The Normans made punishment serve the king.
-
Wergild ends
Fines were now paid to the king rather than to the victim's family, so crime became an offence against royal authority.
-
More capital crimes
Execution was used more, especially for crimes against the king such as rebellion.
-
Mutilation
William preferred mutilation to execution for many crimes: blinding and castration were used, partly to show that offenders still had time to repent.
-
Trial by combat
The accuser and accused fought, often to the death, until one gave in. The loser was hanged if he survived.
Law Enforcement and Courts
The machinery barely changed, but the authority behind it did.
-
Sheriffs
The sheriff became more powerful, collecting fines and taxes and bringing criminals to court for the king.
-
Church courts
William created separate Church courts, which dealt with clergy and moral crimes.
-
Henry II
The Assize of Clarendon (1166) sent royal judges round the country and used juries of local men to report suspects, and ordered new gaols to be built.
-
Castles
Around 500 castles built by 1100 were a constant reminder of Norman power.
How Much Did 1066 Change?
Place each development on the line.
-
1
Tithings and hue and cry
Unchanged: communities still policed themselves
-
2
Trial by ordeal
Unchanged, though now alongside combat
-
3
Courts and sheriffs
Same system, more royal control
-
4
Punishments
Wergild gone; fines to the king
-
5
Forest Laws and murdrum
Brand new crimes to protect Norman power
THE BIG IDEA
The Normans changed who justice served more than how it worked.
The tithing, the hue and cry and the ordeal all survived - but now they protected the king and the conquerors.
Summary & Exam Focus
- William needed to control a hostile population, so his laws protected Norman power.
- New crimes: the Forest Laws and the murdrum fine.
- Tithings, the hue and cry and trial by ordeal continued.
- Wergild ended - fines now went to the king.
Exam focus
"The Norman Conquest brought major changes to crime and punishment in England." How far do you agree? (16 marks) (16 marks)
Argue both sides with specific examples, then judge: continuity in methods, change in whose authority they served.
Key terms
The vocabulary this lesson expects you to use. Each one is linked from the first place it appears above.
- Forest Laws
- Laws making hunting and gathering wood on royal land a crime.
- Poaching
- Illegally hunting animals on land that belonged to someone else.
- Social crime
- A crime most people do not think is really wrong, such as poaching.
- Murdrum fine
- A fine on a whole hundred if a Norman was murdered and the killer not found.
- Trial by combat
- The accuser and accused fought to decide guilt.
- Feudal system
- Land held from the king in return for loyalty and service.
- Assize of Clarendon
- Henry II's law of 1166 that strengthened royal justice.
Downloads
Free to keep, print and annotate.
- Crime and Punishment in Norman England.pptx Built from the lesson script on 23 September 2026. View
- Crime and Punishment in Norman England - Completed Notes.docx The full notes for the lesson, every gap filled in - to check against, or to revise from. Built from the lesson script on 23 September 2026. View
- Crime and Punishment in Norman England - Exam Questions.docx Built from the lesson script on 23 September 2026. View
Something here looks wrong?
Tell us what and we will go and look. It goes to whoever writes these pages, nobody else, and we do not ask who you are — so there is nothing to sign and nothing comes back to you.